Juan Manuel Baitista Castro Unsolved Murder 2023
On December 23 2023 at approximately 5:18PM Fall River Police Department received multiple 911 calls reporting a male shot at 326 Bank Street.
Fall River Police arrived on scene and located Juan Manuel Batista Castro (44) had been fatally shot on the front porch of the residence. A second victim was suffering from a gunshot wound to the hand.
UPDATE: January 25, 2024
Angel Fabian Robles-Nicasio (22) of Willimantic, CT. was charged with Murder, Carrying an Illegal Firearm, and Conspiracy to Traffic Cocaine in connection with the shooting death of Juan Manuel Batista Castro.
On January 23, 2024 Robles-Nicasio was arrested along with eleven (11) other individuals in Connecticut as a result of a long-term investigation by Willimantic Police into a pattern of racketeering and gang activity. He was charged with Corrupt Organization and Racketeering Act and was ordered held on $75,000 bail. With the pending murder charge, Robles-Nicasio, cannot be released from custody even if he posts his Connecticut bail.
On December 23 2023 at approximately 5:18PM Fall River Police Department received multiple 911 calls reporting a male shot at 326 Bank Street.
Fall River Police arrived on scene and located Juan Manuel Batista Castro (44) had been fatally shot on the front porch of the residence. A second victim was suffering from a gunshot wound to the hand.
UPDATE: January 25, 2024
Angel Fabian Robles-Nicasio (22) of Willimantic, CT. was charged with Murder, Carrying an Illegal Firearm, and Conspiracy to Traffic Cocaine in connection with the shooting death of Juan Manuel Batista Castro.
On January 23, 2024 Robles-Nicasio was arrested along with eleven (11) other individuals in Connecticut as a result of a long-term investigation by Willimantic Police into a pattern of racketeering and gang activity. He was charged with Corrupt Organization and Racketeering Act and was ordered held on $75,000 bail. With the pending murder charge, Robles-Nicasio, cannot be released from custody even if he posts his Connecticut bail.
Diamonte Odom Unsolved Murder 2023
On May 13 2023 approximately 10:45 p.m. Fall River Police received calls reporting shots fired near 275 County Street. Upon arrival police located Diamonte Odam (23) laying on the sidewalk. Diamonte was rushed by ambulance to Rhode Island Hospital, where he was pronounced dead at 2:40 a.m. Sunday May 14 2023.
A security camera from across the street also captured video of a person firing a gun seven (7) times and running away. No suspects have been arrested in connection with the shooting at this time.
UPDATE: January 3, 2024
Four (4) men have been been indicated in connection to the murder of Diamonte Odam. Tajon Saxon (26), is also wanted on a default warrant in connection to the May 2021 Fall River double-homicide of Jovaughn Mills and Miguel Sanjurjo, in which he is charged with two counts of accessory to murder after the fact. His whereabout are unknown.
Quanif Johnson (26), currently in custody in Rhode Island on charges connected to a Rhode Island murder, Dioni Tavarez-Leonirio (25) who was arraigned in December 2023 and is being held on $75,000 cash bail, and Devin Alves (18) who was arraigned on January 2 2024 and was ordered held on $7,500 cash bail.
On May 13 2023 approximately 10:45 p.m. Fall River Police received calls reporting shots fired near 275 County Street. Upon arrival police located Diamonte Odam (23) laying on the sidewalk. Diamonte was rushed by ambulance to Rhode Island Hospital, where he was pronounced dead at 2:40 a.m. Sunday May 14 2023.
A security camera from across the street also captured video of a person firing a gun seven (7) times and running away. No suspects have been arrested in connection with the shooting at this time.
UPDATE: January 3, 2024
Four (4) men have been been indicated in connection to the murder of Diamonte Odam. Tajon Saxon (26), is also wanted on a default warrant in connection to the May 2021 Fall River double-homicide of Jovaughn Mills and Miguel Sanjurjo, in which he is charged with two counts of accessory to murder after the fact. His whereabout are unknown.
Quanif Johnson (26), currently in custody in Rhode Island on charges connected to a Rhode Island murder, Dioni Tavarez-Leonirio (25) who was arraigned in December 2023 and is being held on $75,000 cash bail, and Devin Alves (18) who was arraigned on January 2 2024 and was ordered held on $7,500 cash bail.
Joseph Sylvester Jr. Unsolved Murder 2023
On March 23 2023 approximately 11:00pm Fall River Police received calls reporting a stabbing victim near 197 Rodman Street. Joseph Sylvester Jr. (31) was discovered stabbed and laying on the sidewalk. Joseph was transported to Saint Anne’s Hospital and pronounced deceased at 11:45 p.m.
On September 17 2013 Joseph Sylvester, then age 22, was charged with vandalizing property, breaking and entering into a building nighttime for felony and larceny from a building. Joseph was accused of breaking into Neighborhood Variety, 52 N. Main St., on September 2 2013 and Stop and Save, 201 Rock St., on September 10 2013. Joseph was held on $2,000 cash bail after being arraigned in Fall River District Court, had an outstanding arrest warrants from 2010 charging him with assault and battery with a dangerous weapon, assault with a dangerous weapon and armed robbery.
On March 23 2023 approximately 11:00pm Fall River Police received calls reporting a stabbing victim near 197 Rodman Street. Joseph Sylvester Jr. (31) was discovered stabbed and laying on the sidewalk. Joseph was transported to Saint Anne’s Hospital and pronounced deceased at 11:45 p.m.
On September 17 2013 Joseph Sylvester, then age 22, was charged with vandalizing property, breaking and entering into a building nighttime for felony and larceny from a building. Joseph was accused of breaking into Neighborhood Variety, 52 N. Main St., on September 2 2013 and Stop and Save, 201 Rock St., on September 10 2013. Joseph was held on $2,000 cash bail after being arraigned in Fall River District Court, had an outstanding arrest warrants from 2010 charging him with assault and battery with a dangerous weapon, assault with a dangerous weapon and armed robbery.
Leon Brown Undetermined 2022
On August 29, 2005 Fall River police received a report of an unidentified body found has was discovered at the landfill on Airport Road. The body appeared to be of an African American man who seemed to be in his 30s, around 5ft 8in tall, and 170 lbs. An autopsy showed that he recently had medical treatment to his left ankle, and had died within a week of his body being discovered. A full DNA profile was later developed and entered into national databases, no matches were found. The body was buried in the Oak Grove Cemetery.
A search of the landfill suggested his body might have been transported there in a dump truck from Peabody or the North Shore area. The landfill accepted trucks from other cities and towns.
UPDATE: September 1 2022
With advanced fingerprinting techniques, the man has been identified as Leon Brown (41), a Boston resident. Brown went missing in August 2005. He had been living with his girlfriend in Boston at the time of his disappearance. His girlfriend had reported to the police that she woke up at some point in August of 2005, and he was missing.
Investigators are now probing this case as a suspicious death based on all of the circumstances surrounding Mr. Brown’s disappearance, death and the disposal of his body in the Fall River landfill.
Brown suffered from multiple sclerosis and had difficulty walking and used leg braces. The leg braces were not on his legs nor found in the landfill with his body.
On August 29, 2005 Fall River police received a report of an unidentified body found has was discovered at the landfill on Airport Road. The body appeared to be of an African American man who seemed to be in his 30s, around 5ft 8in tall, and 170 lbs. An autopsy showed that he recently had medical treatment to his left ankle, and had died within a week of his body being discovered. A full DNA profile was later developed and entered into national databases, no matches were found. The body was buried in the Oak Grove Cemetery.
A search of the landfill suggested his body might have been transported there in a dump truck from Peabody or the North Shore area. The landfill accepted trucks from other cities and towns.
UPDATE: September 1 2022
With advanced fingerprinting techniques, the man has been identified as Leon Brown (41), a Boston resident. Brown went missing in August 2005. He had been living with his girlfriend in Boston at the time of his disappearance. His girlfriend had reported to the police that she woke up at some point in August of 2005, and he was missing.
Investigators are now probing this case as a suspicious death based on all of the circumstances surrounding Mr. Brown’s disappearance, death and the disposal of his body in the Fall River landfill.
Brown suffered from multiple sclerosis and had difficulty walking and used leg braces. The leg braces were not on his legs nor found in the landfill with his body.
Vincent Wadlington Unsolved Murder 2011
On February 17 2011 around 5:45 p.m. Vincent Wadlington (25) was discovered deceased laying across the railroad tracks in the area of Danforth Street, near the intersection of Durfee and Odd Streets. Vincent appeared to have been stabbed several times. His death was ruled a homicide.
The night before his body was discovered, Vincent called the Fall River Police and expressed concern about the wellbeing of an ex-girlfriend. Vincent met officers at a friend’s apartment, and officers drove him from there to a convenience store at the corner of North Main Street and President Avenue. Vincent walked to his sister's home on Brownell Street, rang the doorbell, but no one answered. Vincent's belongings were found abandoned on her front steps.
Vincent was known to the Fall River Police and had history of drug related struggles. At the time of his death, he had successfully completed a drug rehab program and was employed. Investigators have pursued numerous leads and persons of interest, but all of them have been positively ruled out. Detectives have yet to identify additional suspects.
On February 17 2011 around 5:45 p.m. Vincent Wadlington (25) was discovered deceased laying across the railroad tracks in the area of Danforth Street, near the intersection of Durfee and Odd Streets. Vincent appeared to have been stabbed several times. His death was ruled a homicide.
The night before his body was discovered, Vincent called the Fall River Police and expressed concern about the wellbeing of an ex-girlfriend. Vincent met officers at a friend’s apartment, and officers drove him from there to a convenience store at the corner of North Main Street and President Avenue. Vincent walked to his sister's home on Brownell Street, rang the doorbell, but no one answered. Vincent's belongings were found abandoned on her front steps.
Vincent was known to the Fall River Police and had history of drug related struggles. At the time of his death, he had successfully completed a drug rehab program and was employed. Investigators have pursued numerous leads and persons of interest, but all of them have been positively ruled out. Detectives have yet to identify additional suspects.
Angel Robles Rivera Unsolved Murder 2010
On July 9 2010 Angel Robles Rivera (33) was shot inside his home located at 275 County Street. Witnesses reported seeing two (2) men fleeing form the scene in a dark gray (or silver) SUV type vehicle immediately after the shooting.
On July 9 2010 Angel Robles Rivera (33) was shot inside his home located at 275 County Street. Witnesses reported seeing two (2) men fleeing form the scene in a dark gray (or silver) SUV type vehicle immediately after the shooting.
Eric Sullivan Unsolved Murder 2008
On October 29 2008 Eric Sullivan (20) was shot and killed across the street from the now boarded-up Larry's Sports Pub. It remains unknown why Sullivan was near Larry’s Sports Bar that night. Approximately 9:30 p.m. Fall River Police were dispatched to the area and discovered Sullivan had suffered a single gunshot to the abdomen and was transported to Rhode Island Hospital where he was pronounced dead.
After being shot, Sullivan was seen banging on a number of doors along the street. Investigators determined robbery wasn't the motive, his cell phone and a bag of marijuana were recovered at the scene. Sullivan had a lengthy criminal history in Fall River District Court, including drug charges, resisting arrest, vandalizing property, armed assault to murder, receiving a stolen motor vehicle and more, but most of the charges were dismissed. Sullivan did serve one six-month term in the Bristol County House of Correction for a conviction on a drug possession charge.
Suspects Arrested
Brianna Gatta (18) was arrested by investigators for misleading police with the intent to obstruct or delay the investigation the murder of Eric Sullivan. Gatta was the first person charged in connection the Sullivan's murder. Investigators obtained a list of all incoming and outgoing calls from Sullivan's cell phone from before and after his death. The numbers were traced to numbers belonging to Sullivan's family, friends or coworkers except for one number. That one number belonged to Brianna Gatta. Ten (10) phone calls were made from Gatta's cellphone to Sullivan between 7 p.m. and 9:18 p.m. Gatta was also with Elijah Judge, who police claimed is a known drug dealer and was known to be armed.
A search warrant was issued on Gatta's apartment, the search resulted in discovering court documents containing Judge's name, men's clothing and other personal item belonging to him. Gatta admitted to investigators the phone number did belong to her, but she had not used it in some time. She also initially denied knowing Elijah Judge but later admitted she had a past relationship with him. Gatta denied having any knowledge of Sullivan's death. She was convicted on misleading police with intent. On Nov 6 2013 she filed an appeal of the conviction, which was denied.
Elijah Judge (21) was arrested by investigators for misleading police with the intent to obstruct or delay the investigation the murder of Eric Sullivan. Judge was apprehended by a joint Massachusetts State Police / Boston Police Gang Unit on the outstanding warrant. Judge admitted he had a prior relationship with Gatta.
Neither Gatta nor Judge were charged with Sullivan's death, the case remains unsolved.
Connection to 2005 Shooting at Larry's Sports Pub
The investigation into Sullivan's murder led back to an interesting connection to a 2005 shooting at Larry's Sports Pub. Elijah Judge is the brother of Shane and Helana Judge.
On April 16 2005 Shane and Helana Judge were shot by Nigel Vaughn (21) over a dispute about a sweatshirt being knocked off a bar stool. Helena Judge, at the time of the shooting was three (3) months pregnant and lost the child as a result of the incident.
On April 18 2005, just two days after the shooting, Nigel Vaughan was arrested for being in possession of $1800 and nine (9) bags of cocaine. On August 16 2005 Vaughn was convicted on three (3) counts each of armed assault to murder and mayhem, and a single count of unlawful possession of ammunition. In 2007 Vaughn was sentenced to 18-20 years in prison for his participation in the shooting.
On October 29 2008 Eric Sullivan (20) was shot and killed across the street from the now boarded-up Larry's Sports Pub. It remains unknown why Sullivan was near Larry’s Sports Bar that night. Approximately 9:30 p.m. Fall River Police were dispatched to the area and discovered Sullivan had suffered a single gunshot to the abdomen and was transported to Rhode Island Hospital where he was pronounced dead.
After being shot, Sullivan was seen banging on a number of doors along the street. Investigators determined robbery wasn't the motive, his cell phone and a bag of marijuana were recovered at the scene. Sullivan had a lengthy criminal history in Fall River District Court, including drug charges, resisting arrest, vandalizing property, armed assault to murder, receiving a stolen motor vehicle and more, but most of the charges were dismissed. Sullivan did serve one six-month term in the Bristol County House of Correction for a conviction on a drug possession charge.
Suspects Arrested
Brianna Gatta (18) was arrested by investigators for misleading police with the intent to obstruct or delay the investigation the murder of Eric Sullivan. Gatta was the first person charged in connection the Sullivan's murder. Investigators obtained a list of all incoming and outgoing calls from Sullivan's cell phone from before and after his death. The numbers were traced to numbers belonging to Sullivan's family, friends or coworkers except for one number. That one number belonged to Brianna Gatta. Ten (10) phone calls were made from Gatta's cellphone to Sullivan between 7 p.m. and 9:18 p.m. Gatta was also with Elijah Judge, who police claimed is a known drug dealer and was known to be armed.
A search warrant was issued on Gatta's apartment, the search resulted in discovering court documents containing Judge's name, men's clothing and other personal item belonging to him. Gatta admitted to investigators the phone number did belong to her, but she had not used it in some time. She also initially denied knowing Elijah Judge but later admitted she had a past relationship with him. Gatta denied having any knowledge of Sullivan's death. She was convicted on misleading police with intent. On Nov 6 2013 she filed an appeal of the conviction, which was denied.
Elijah Judge (21) was arrested by investigators for misleading police with the intent to obstruct or delay the investigation the murder of Eric Sullivan. Judge was apprehended by a joint Massachusetts State Police / Boston Police Gang Unit on the outstanding warrant. Judge admitted he had a prior relationship with Gatta.
Neither Gatta nor Judge were charged with Sullivan's death, the case remains unsolved.
Connection to 2005 Shooting at Larry's Sports Pub
The investigation into Sullivan's murder led back to an interesting connection to a 2005 shooting at Larry's Sports Pub. Elijah Judge is the brother of Shane and Helana Judge.
On April 16 2005 Shane and Helana Judge were shot by Nigel Vaughn (21) over a dispute about a sweatshirt being knocked off a bar stool. Helena Judge, at the time of the shooting was three (3) months pregnant and lost the child as a result of the incident.
On April 18 2005, just two days after the shooting, Nigel Vaughan was arrested for being in possession of $1800 and nine (9) bags of cocaine. On August 16 2005 Vaughn was convicted on three (3) counts each of armed assault to murder and mayhem, and a single count of unlawful possession of ammunition. In 2007 Vaughn was sentenced to 18-20 years in prison for his participation in the shooting.
Oranuch B. Sousa Unsolved Murder 2001
On June 16 2001 approximately 1:30 P.M. the body of Oranuch Sousa (48) was discovered in an open grassy field at the end of Griffin Street, behind a shopping plaza. Autopsy determined cause of death was blunt force trauma to her head.
Sousa had been divorced for six (6) years and had contacted her ex-husband Joseph Sousa (40) meet with her to discuss her request for additional money for her support. Joseph Sousa agreed to meet with Oranuch and drove his motorcycle to the meeting. The day after the murder, Joseph's girlfriend came forward reported to police seeing Joseph burning and burying a pair of jeans that appeared to have blood stains in his backyard.
In May 2002 investigators conducted an extensive search of his yard. They recovered multiple motorcycle related objects, recovered fibers and fabrics as well as dirt samples. Joseph Souza was not charged with any crimes relating to this murder.
On June 16 2001 approximately 1:30 P.M. the body of Oranuch Sousa (48) was discovered in an open grassy field at the end of Griffin Street, behind a shopping plaza. Autopsy determined cause of death was blunt force trauma to her head.
Sousa had been divorced for six (6) years and had contacted her ex-husband Joseph Sousa (40) meet with her to discuss her request for additional money for her support. Joseph Sousa agreed to meet with Oranuch and drove his motorcycle to the meeting. The day after the murder, Joseph's girlfriend came forward reported to police seeing Joseph burning and burying a pair of jeans that appeared to have blood stains in his backyard.
In May 2002 investigators conducted an extensive search of his yard. They recovered multiple motorcycle related objects, recovered fibers and fabrics as well as dirt samples. Joseph Souza was not charged with any crimes relating to this murder.
Brian M. Tupaj Unsolved Murder 1998
Brian Tupaj (24) was discovered laying in the intersection of Lexington and Albion Streets on July 4 1998 at 1:30AM. He appeared to be suffering from a gunshot wound to the head, and was pronounced dead at 5:30AM at Rhode Island Hospital. Two unidentified men were seen running from the scene running down Albion Street, however witnesses were unable to provide clear descriptions. No weapon was recovered at the scene. Little is known about how Mr. Tupaj spent the last hour of his life
Police were also investigating the possibility of a connection between the shooting death of Tupaj and an armed robbery that occurred later Saturday morning in the same vicinity. A man reported to police that he was assaulted and pistol-whipped by at least four people at 330 a.m. However, he was not able to give police any description.
Brian Tupaj (24) was discovered laying in the intersection of Lexington and Albion Streets on July 4 1998 at 1:30AM. He appeared to be suffering from a gunshot wound to the head, and was pronounced dead at 5:30AM at Rhode Island Hospital. Two unidentified men were seen running from the scene running down Albion Street, however witnesses were unable to provide clear descriptions. No weapon was recovered at the scene. Little is known about how Mr. Tupaj spent the last hour of his life
Police were also investigating the possibility of a connection between the shooting death of Tupaj and an armed robbery that occurred later Saturday morning in the same vicinity. A man reported to police that he was assaulted and pistol-whipped by at least four people at 330 a.m. However, he was not able to give police any description.
John M. Medeiros Unsolved Murder 1994
Joseph M. Medeiros was a Fall River insurance agent with Troy Insurance Company and was involved in this area’s gambling scene. He was shot in the chest multiple times while sitting inside his parked van on the dirt road near Cook Pond on February 24 1994. Medeiros returned from a trip to Georgia (Superbowl XXVII) the day before he was murdered. Many of the possible suspects that were identified are incarcerated or dead. Investigators believe his murder is tied to organized crime.
Joseph M. Medeiros was a Fall River insurance agent with Troy Insurance Company and was involved in this area’s gambling scene. He was shot in the chest multiple times while sitting inside his parked van on the dirt road near Cook Pond on February 24 1994. Medeiros returned from a trip to Georgia (Superbowl XXVII) the day before he was murdered. Many of the possible suspects that were identified are incarcerated or dead. Investigators believe his murder is tied to organized crime.
Carlos Enrique Hernandez Unsolved Murder 1991
On July 19 1991 the partially nude body of Hernandez was discovered lying in a secluded wooded area off of Henry Street. Autopsy results determined he had been shot twice in the head, and once in the back. Hernandez was discovered with his arms and head wrapped in a brown trash bag. Investigators determined he was dumped there, and it remains unknown where that actual crime took place.
Hernandez was a native of Bogota Columbia, but was a resident of Cranston Rhode Island. Hernandez had a criminal record in Rhode Island and Massachusetts.
On July 19 1991 the partially nude body of Hernandez was discovered lying in a secluded wooded area off of Henry Street. Autopsy results determined he had been shot twice in the head, and once in the back. Hernandez was discovered with his arms and head wrapped in a brown trash bag. Investigators determined he was dumped there, and it remains unknown where that actual crime took place.
Hernandez was a native of Bogota Columbia, but was a resident of Cranston Rhode Island. Hernandez had a criminal record in Rhode Island and Massachusetts.
Thomas Picard Unsolved Murder 1988
On October 2 1988 Thomas Picard (11) was reported missing to the Fall River Police Department by his mother. She reported she last saw him on October 1 1988 wearing gray pants, striped shirt and white sneakers. During the search for Thomas, several witnesses reported seeing him near the intersection of Dwelly and South Main Streets. On November 24 1989 his bicycle was located in the bushes near Cook Pond.
On January 7 1989 two (2) boys discovered the fully-clothed body of Thomas Picard in the shallow portion of Cook Pond. An autopsy reported indicated the cause of death as asphyxiation.
Picard Family
The Picard family had five (5) children, Jennifer, Harry, Douglas, Shelly, Thomas. Jennifer, Douglas and Shelly are now deceased. Their father Harold died 16 days after Thomas went missing from a liver ailment.
Boston Globe Article
A Boston Globe story at the time quoted Thomas's mother, Judith Picard, stating that police had informed her they were close to making an arrest. She stated police identified a suspect and intend to arrest him shortly. This suspect is in his 30's and a native of Fall River. No one has ever been arrested, his murder remains unsolved.
On October 2 1988 Thomas Picard (11) was reported missing to the Fall River Police Department by his mother. She reported she last saw him on October 1 1988 wearing gray pants, striped shirt and white sneakers. During the search for Thomas, several witnesses reported seeing him near the intersection of Dwelly and South Main Streets. On November 24 1989 his bicycle was located in the bushes near Cook Pond.
On January 7 1989 two (2) boys discovered the fully-clothed body of Thomas Picard in the shallow portion of Cook Pond. An autopsy reported indicated the cause of death as asphyxiation.
Picard Family
The Picard family had five (5) children, Jennifer, Harry, Douglas, Shelly, Thomas. Jennifer, Douglas and Shelly are now deceased. Their father Harold died 16 days after Thomas went missing from a liver ailment.
Boston Globe Article
A Boston Globe story at the time quoted Thomas's mother, Judith Picard, stating that police had informed her they were close to making an arrest. She stated police identified a suspect and intend to arrest him shortly. This suspect is in his 30's and a native of Fall River. No one has ever been arrested, his murder remains unsolved.
Sandra J. Showers Unsolved Murder 1982 On August 8 1982, Sandra Showers (24) dropped her baby off with her mother in the afternoon and was headed to Cook Pond. Sandra was expected to return back to pick up her son, she had left just enough formula for the time she was supposed to be gone. Sandra was wearing shorts and bathing suit, with a towel and had a portable radio. Bruce Ferreira picked up Sandra at her mother's house in his van. Gayle Bryan (29), Sandra's friend, was already in the van. It's unclear what exactly happened that day.
On August 10 1982 Sandra's body was discovered, still wearing her bathing suit, on the Tiverton R.I. side of the pond by two (2) boys fishing. Sandra was known to go swimming, but never took off her shorts to swim she had a complex about that. Sandra's belongings were located in a trash bin. Her remains showed no signs of external injuries. The autopsy report states the cause of death was asphyxiation secondary to drowning from a blow to her head. Sandra is buried in Oak Grove Cemetery.
Gail explained a different story, she claimed the two (2) women went to the pond along with Bruce Ferreira around midnight on August 8, 1982 after drinking at the Penthouse Lounge. Ferreira drove the women in his van to the pier where they had access to the pond. Ferreira remained at the pond with them. Gail admitted they smoked marijuana together before obtaining a ride from Ferreira to the pond. Gail claimed Sandra insisted on going swimming, so she pushed her into the pond. Sandra never surfaced, Gail claimed she waited 30 minutes then left the pond, never notifying anyone of the incident. Ferreira was never questioned.
Gail was was arrested and charged with manslaughter, which she plead innocent to the charges at her arraignment. On December 20 1983 Gail was acquitted of all charges by Judge Roger Sullivan. Judge Sullivan found no probable cause and no evidence to support Gail had caused the death of Sandra Showers.
Discrepancies Discovered
The investigation into Sandra's death raises questions. The Fall River Police detective assigned to the investigation had a previous relationship with Gail Bryan. The police never questioned any family members about the last time Sandra was seen nor did they inquire about her infant son.
Family Response April 2022
This is the first time I've actually heard what they said happened to my sister. My family was never interviewed, on when they last seen my sister that day. Police never showed to talk to the family nor did they come to the house to tell my mother of my sisters death.
The detective that Gail was seeing (dating) supposedly was the one who Gail turned herself into resulting in her arrested.
I truly believe that this was covered up. Why her case wasn't solved is beyond me. My family knows Gail and entire family since childhood No one will talk...and everyone who did step forward to speak was threatened. Several times one of my family members were set to meet up with someone who had information and they never showed up. My family was threatened to not force the investigation. Who threatened them, I was never told. I was just told to leave it alone. Gail and Bruce burned my sister's clothing in the trash bin. If there was nothing to hide why do that ?
Sandra and Gail weren't very good friends, there was animosity between them. Arguments and physical altercations occurred.
On August 10 1982 Sandra's body was discovered, still wearing her bathing suit, on the Tiverton R.I. side of the pond by two (2) boys fishing. Sandra was known to go swimming, but never took off her shorts to swim she had a complex about that. Sandra's belongings were located in a trash bin. Her remains showed no signs of external injuries. The autopsy report states the cause of death was asphyxiation secondary to drowning from a blow to her head. Sandra is buried in Oak Grove Cemetery.
Gail explained a different story, she claimed the two (2) women went to the pond along with Bruce Ferreira around midnight on August 8, 1982 after drinking at the Penthouse Lounge. Ferreira drove the women in his van to the pier where they had access to the pond. Ferreira remained at the pond with them. Gail admitted they smoked marijuana together before obtaining a ride from Ferreira to the pond. Gail claimed Sandra insisted on going swimming, so she pushed her into the pond. Sandra never surfaced, Gail claimed she waited 30 minutes then left the pond, never notifying anyone of the incident. Ferreira was never questioned.
Gail was was arrested and charged with manslaughter, which she plead innocent to the charges at her arraignment. On December 20 1983 Gail was acquitted of all charges by Judge Roger Sullivan. Judge Sullivan found no probable cause and no evidence to support Gail had caused the death of Sandra Showers.
Discrepancies Discovered
The investigation into Sandra's death raises questions. The Fall River Police detective assigned to the investigation had a previous relationship with Gail Bryan. The police never questioned any family members about the last time Sandra was seen nor did they inquire about her infant son.
Family Response April 2022
This is the first time I've actually heard what they said happened to my sister. My family was never interviewed, on when they last seen my sister that day. Police never showed to talk to the family nor did they come to the house to tell my mother of my sisters death.
The detective that Gail was seeing (dating) supposedly was the one who Gail turned herself into resulting in her arrested.
I truly believe that this was covered up. Why her case wasn't solved is beyond me. My family knows Gail and entire family since childhood No one will talk...and everyone who did step forward to speak was threatened. Several times one of my family members were set to meet up with someone who had information and they never showed up. My family was threatened to not force the investigation. Who threatened them, I was never told. I was just told to leave it alone. Gail and Bruce burned my sister's clothing in the trash bin. If there was nothing to hide why do that ?
Sandra and Gail weren't very good friends, there was animosity between them. Arguments and physical altercations occurred.
Abbie K. Rosofsky Unsolved Murder 1975 Abbie K. Rosofsky (16) was attending the Aerosmith concert in North Park when she was beaten and strangled to death. Her body was discovered about 11:30PM in the upper section of the park, away from the area where an estimated 12,000 concert-goers were seated. The autopsy determined the time of death was around 9PM and no evidence of sexual assault.
John Reis (17) said he met Abbie for a prearranged date at North Park, went to her home for a jacket, met her sister and then returned to the park. Abbie gave him a coke, and he passed out after drinking it. He contended that he was drugged and denied killing her. Reis was taken into custody and charged with murder and ordered held without bail. Reis had only been in the Unites States for eight (8) months at the time and was previously employed by Rosofsky's father at a local clothing company. In December 1977 Reis was put on trial, after 9 hours the jury acquitted Reis of the murder. After trial Reis returned the Azores.
John Reis (17) said he met Abbie for a prearranged date at North Park, went to her home for a jacket, met her sister and then returned to the park. Abbie gave him a coke, and he passed out after drinking it. He contended that he was drugged and denied killing her. Reis was taken into custody and charged with murder and ordered held without bail. Reis had only been in the Unites States for eight (8) months at the time and was previously employed by Rosofsky's father at a local clothing company. In December 1977 Reis was put on trial, after 9 hours the jury acquitted Reis of the murder. After trial Reis returned the Azores.
Kenneth "Kenny" Pemberton Unsolved Murder 1972
On August 3 1972 Kenneth P. Pemberton (1946-1972), a 3-time Golden Glove boxing champion, was shot four (4) times while leaving a Fall River cafe around 11:30PM.
As Pemberton lay dead on the embalming table at a New Bedford funeral home, an unknown individual broken into the funeral home, doused Pemberton's body with lighter fluid and set his body on fire. Prior to his death, Pemberton has identified two (2) men who were involved in a shooting incident that took place a few weeks prior.
In 1968 Pemberton was charged with 1st-degree murder in the death of Manuel DeSilva (75) of Rochester. DeSilva died of a fractured skull infected by a blunt object. Pemberton was accused of using his fists and whetstone to murder DeSilva. His body was discovered on Oct 31 1968 in his tool shed at the rear of his home. It was determined robbery was the motive. Pemberton was acquitted in 1969. Laid to rest in St John's Cemetery New Bedford.
On August 3 1972 Kenneth P. Pemberton (1946-1972), a 3-time Golden Glove boxing champion, was shot four (4) times while leaving a Fall River cafe around 11:30PM.
As Pemberton lay dead on the embalming table at a New Bedford funeral home, an unknown individual broken into the funeral home, doused Pemberton's body with lighter fluid and set his body on fire. Prior to his death, Pemberton has identified two (2) men who were involved in a shooting incident that took place a few weeks prior.
In 1968 Pemberton was charged with 1st-degree murder in the death of Manuel DeSilva (75) of Rochester. DeSilva died of a fractured skull infected by a blunt object. Pemberton was accused of using his fists and whetstone to murder DeSilva. His body was discovered on Oct 31 1968 in his tool shed at the rear of his home. It was determined robbery was the motive. Pemberton was acquitted in 1969. Laid to rest in St John's Cemetery New Bedford.
Leonard E. Ramos Unsolved Murder 1970
On October 11 1970 Roy E. Corby (39) allegedly entered Star Liquors located at 1513 Pleasant St.
According to the Fall River Herald, Corby went to the store with the intent to commit a robbery.
Leonard Ramos (22) a part-time clerk at the store told police "a tall elderly man with gray hair"
entered the store and ordered beer. Ramos then went to the walk-in cooler at the rear of the store, and Corby followed him.
Once at the cooler door, Corby displayed a handgun, ordered Ramos into the walk-in cooler.
Once secured, Corby then attempted to gain entry to the registry drawer, without success.
Corby then returned to the walk-in cooler and ordered Ramos to open the register. Once open, Corby took $250 and ordered Ramos back to the walk-in cooler.
Just outside the walk-in cooler, Corby allegedly said "I'm sorry" and shot Ramos three (3) times and fled the scene. Ramos, wounded, was able to call Fall River Police.
Ramos was shot once in the left arm, and twice in the stomach. He was transported to the hospital, under went emergency surgery and was then listed in fair condition. while recovering, Fall River Police transported Corby to the hospital for Ramos to identify as his assailant. As a result Corby was arrested and charged with armed robbery and assault to murder, in court he plead innocent.
On October 21 1970 Leonard Ramos died as a result of peritonitis due the gunshot wounds to the abdomen. Corby was now charged with 1st degree murder. Corby plead innocent in Fall River District Court and was ordered held without bail at the New Bedford House of Correction pending preliminary hearing.
A grand jury indicted Corby on armed robbery and 1st degree murder. On March 26, 1971 New Bedford Superior Court Judge Andrew Linscott allowed the defense motion to suppress the identification made by Ramos in the hospital. The defense contended Corby was brought in by two (2) Fall River police officers in handcuffs, no lineup was used, additionally there were no witnesses to the crime.
On October 9 1971 The Bristol County District Attorney dismissed all the charges against Corby due to lack of evidence.
The case remains unsolved.
On October 11 1970 Roy E. Corby (39) allegedly entered Star Liquors located at 1513 Pleasant St.
According to the Fall River Herald, Corby went to the store with the intent to commit a robbery.
Leonard Ramos (22) a part-time clerk at the store told police "a tall elderly man with gray hair"
entered the store and ordered beer. Ramos then went to the walk-in cooler at the rear of the store, and Corby followed him.
Once at the cooler door, Corby displayed a handgun, ordered Ramos into the walk-in cooler.
Once secured, Corby then attempted to gain entry to the registry drawer, without success.
Corby then returned to the walk-in cooler and ordered Ramos to open the register. Once open, Corby took $250 and ordered Ramos back to the walk-in cooler.
Just outside the walk-in cooler, Corby allegedly said "I'm sorry" and shot Ramos three (3) times and fled the scene. Ramos, wounded, was able to call Fall River Police.
Ramos was shot once in the left arm, and twice in the stomach. He was transported to the hospital, under went emergency surgery and was then listed in fair condition. while recovering, Fall River Police transported Corby to the hospital for Ramos to identify as his assailant. As a result Corby was arrested and charged with armed robbery and assault to murder, in court he plead innocent.
On October 21 1970 Leonard Ramos died as a result of peritonitis due the gunshot wounds to the abdomen. Corby was now charged with 1st degree murder. Corby plead innocent in Fall River District Court and was ordered held without bail at the New Bedford House of Correction pending preliminary hearing.
A grand jury indicted Corby on armed robbery and 1st degree murder. On March 26, 1971 New Bedford Superior Court Judge Andrew Linscott allowed the defense motion to suppress the identification made by Ramos in the hospital. The defense contended Corby was brought in by two (2) Fall River police officers in handcuffs, no lineup was used, additionally there were no witnesses to the crime.
On October 9 1971 The Bristol County District Attorney dismissed all the charges against Corby due to lack of evidence.
The case remains unsolved.
Russell Goldstein Unsolved Murder 1969 Russell Goldstein resided at 420 South Main Street and operated an antique store across the street named "RussGold Sporting Goods". Goldstein bought and sold guns and antiques. He was very lax in what he purchased and certainly could've purchased stolen items.
On December 20, 1969 Goldstein was shot and killed inside his apartment. Goldstein was bludgeoned in the head with an object and then shot four (4) times with two (2) different caliber weapons. Three (3) wounds were from a .22 caliber (chest, ear, thigh) and the fourth wound from a .45 caliber in the hand.
The killer(s) gained entry into his apartment, it appears he knew the assailant(s) since no signs of forced entry. At the time of his death, Goldstein was under investigation by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms (ATF).
Sergeant Paul Gonsalves - Fall River Police Department
Suspicion fell on Sgt. Paul Gonsalves of the Fall River Police Department. Gonsalves, as it was later discovered, ran a gang of burglars and was suspected of fencing much of the stolen goods through Goldstein. On May 10 1969, there was a failed attempt on Goldstein’s life with Gonsalves being the prime suspect. On June 11, 1969 Gonsalves was arrested and charged with conspiracy to commit murder, but charges were dropped on July 29 1969.
Although Gonsalves was later convicted of extortion and check fraud, for which he would serve time in prison, he was never charged with either the attempted murder on Goldstein or the murder itself.
Three (3) others involved with Sgt Gonsalves in the breaking and entering ring suspiciously ended up dead. Frank Cabral October 5, 1969 died in a motor vehicle crash, Thomas Collins July 19, 1969 was found hung inside the Fall River Police holding cell (Police involvement was suspected, but never proven) and Norman V. Tremblay III (17) October 14, 1969 hung himself while handcuffed in his own backyard. The two (2) suicides were suspicious.
Suspects Arrested and Acquitted
Two men were later arrested and charged with conspiracy to commit murder, John Russell St. Martin Jr. and William Lamphiere. However, they went on trial and were later acquitted.
On December 20, 1969 Goldstein was shot and killed inside his apartment. Goldstein was bludgeoned in the head with an object and then shot four (4) times with two (2) different caliber weapons. Three (3) wounds were from a .22 caliber (chest, ear, thigh) and the fourth wound from a .45 caliber in the hand.
The killer(s) gained entry into his apartment, it appears he knew the assailant(s) since no signs of forced entry. At the time of his death, Goldstein was under investigation by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms (ATF).
Sergeant Paul Gonsalves - Fall River Police Department
Suspicion fell on Sgt. Paul Gonsalves of the Fall River Police Department. Gonsalves, as it was later discovered, ran a gang of burglars and was suspected of fencing much of the stolen goods through Goldstein. On May 10 1969, there was a failed attempt on Goldstein’s life with Gonsalves being the prime suspect. On June 11, 1969 Gonsalves was arrested and charged with conspiracy to commit murder, but charges were dropped on July 29 1969.
Although Gonsalves was later convicted of extortion and check fraud, for which he would serve time in prison, he was never charged with either the attempted murder on Goldstein or the murder itself.
Three (3) others involved with Sgt Gonsalves in the breaking and entering ring suspiciously ended up dead. Frank Cabral October 5, 1969 died in a motor vehicle crash, Thomas Collins July 19, 1969 was found hung inside the Fall River Police holding cell (Police involvement was suspected, but never proven) and Norman V. Tremblay III (17) October 14, 1969 hung himself while handcuffed in his own backyard. The two (2) suicides were suspicious.
Suspects Arrested and Acquitted
Two men were later arrested and charged with conspiracy to commit murder, John Russell St. Martin Jr. and William Lamphiere. However, they went on trial and were later acquitted.
Louis Chouinard Unsolved Murder 1925 On Dec 5 1925 Louis Chouinard, along with his son Auguste, pulled up in front of their home at 31 Choate Street. As Louis was exiting his vehicle two (2) unknown young men brandished firearms in an attempt to rob him of the proceeds from their family owned grocery store at 221 Flint Street ($1000).
Louis was shot in the abdomen and died on Dec 10 1925 from blood poisoning from being shot. Auguste had a weapon placed against his head, the assailant pulled the trigger but the firearm failed to discharge, he was then pistol-whipped. Auguste began shouting for help, resulting in the suspects fleeing the scene without any money.
Fall River Police Officer Calsse who resided on the third floor of the tenement house gave chase of the suspects. He chased one of the suspects thru backyards but lost sight of him near Notre Dame Church.
A handkerchief was recovered near the scene of the robbery, for the first time in history German Shepards owned by a local doctor were brought in to attempt to locate the suspects. The trail went cold.
Louis was shot in the abdomen and died on Dec 10 1925 from blood poisoning from being shot. Auguste had a weapon placed against his head, the assailant pulled the trigger but the firearm failed to discharge, he was then pistol-whipped. Auguste began shouting for help, resulting in the suspects fleeing the scene without any money.
Fall River Police Officer Calsse who resided on the third floor of the tenement house gave chase of the suspects. He chased one of the suspects thru backyards but lost sight of him near Notre Dame Church.
A handkerchief was recovered near the scene of the robbery, for the first time in history German Shepards owned by a local doctor were brought in to attempt to locate the suspects. The trail went cold.
Borden Murders Unsolved Murders 1892 The Borden murders is difficult to accurately describe since there are so many books written, each with different interpretations, theories and opinions.
August 4 1892 Murder at 92 Second Street
At approximately 930AM Abby Borden was killed in the second-floor guest room with a hatchet, striking her 19 times in the head. 90 minutes later approx 11AM Andrew Borden was likewise attacked with a hatchet be stuck 11 times to the head as he was resting on the sofa in the sitting room.
The only present during this time frame was Lizzie and the house maid Bridget Sullivan. Emma, Lizzie's sister was in Fairhaven. Lizzie became as suspect due to her "odd" behavior, she expressed no emotion. Lizzie was arrested and charged with murder.
The trial began on June 5 1893 in New Bedford Superior Court and lasted until June 20 1893. The jury heard lots of testimony and viewed evidence presented evidence during the trial, and then deliberated for barely one (1) hour before returning the verdict..."Not Guilty" at 3:42PM.
Lizzie A.Borden (1860-1927)
After the trial, Lizzie and Emma moved into a new house that Lizzie named "Maplecroft". The sisters settled all claims against them from Abby's side of the family, giving Abby Borden's family members everything, they wanted in order to avoid further lawsuits. It was determined that Abby died before Andrew, all of her estate legally went to Andrew, with Andrew's estate going to his daughters. The settlement reached between the Borden sisters and Abby's two sisters was substantial.
In June 1905, Lizzie and Emma Borden became estranged over differences in their lifestyles. Emma moved out of the house and moved in with her close friend Alice Lydia Buck. After the separation from her sister, Lizzie began using the name "Lizbeth A. Borden", rather than "Lizzie".
Following the surgical removal of her gallbladder, Lizzie was ill the last year of her life. Lizzie died of pneumonia on June 1, 1927. Lizzie's funeral details were not made public and few people attended her burial. She was buried in Oak Grove Cemetery under the name "Lizbeth Andrew Borden", her footstone was inscribed "Lizbeth". Lizzie never married, and her will, left $30,000 to the Fall River Animal Rescue League, $500 in perpetual trust for the care of her father's grave. Much of her wealth was transferred to her cousin Grace H. Howe, and her closest friend Helen Leighton. Nine days later, on June 10, 1927, her sister Emma died
Bridget Sullivan (1869-1948)
According to trial transcripts Bridget testified she prepared a meal for the Bordens and then was sent by Abby Borden to wash the windows. After finishing the windows in the heat, she retired to her room on the third-floor attic to rest, as she felt ill.
At 11:10AM Lizzie called to her "Maggie come quick! Father's dead, somebody came in and killed him." It was Bridget that discovered the body of Abby Borden dead in her bedroom. Bridget provided key testimony at the inquest, preliminary hearing and final trial of Lizzie Borden, who was later acquitted of all charges.
Bridget was born in Ireland and emigrated to the USA on May 24 1886 arriving in New York aboard the SS Republic. She began work as a maid in Newport, RI then moved to South Bethlehem Pennsylvania and lived with relatives. In 1888 Sullivan moved to Fall River Mass and worked as a cook for Lawyer Charles Reed, who resided in the Highland section of the city. In 1889 she then moved to the residence of Clinton Remington, also in the Highland section of the city. In November 1889 Bridget began her employment with the Borden Family.
After the trial in 1893, Bridget returned to Ireland with the help of Lizzie and Emma. Bridget later moved back to the USA and settled in Anaconda Montana, and in 1896 became the maid for Attorney George Winston (1861-1936). She remained employed by Winston until his death, never mentioning the murders in Massachusetts.
In 1905, Sullivan married John Sullivan (1868-1939) who was a copper smelting furnace man. In 1910 they resided at 412 Monroe St., then later moved to 701 Alder St where they lived for many years. After John Sullivan's death in 1939 she moved to Butte Montana and resided there until her death. Bridget and John are buried in Mount Olivet Cemetery in Anaconda Montana.
August 4 1892 Murder at 92 Second Street
At approximately 930AM Abby Borden was killed in the second-floor guest room with a hatchet, striking her 19 times in the head. 90 minutes later approx 11AM Andrew Borden was likewise attacked with a hatchet be stuck 11 times to the head as he was resting on the sofa in the sitting room.
The only present during this time frame was Lizzie and the house maid Bridget Sullivan. Emma, Lizzie's sister was in Fairhaven. Lizzie became as suspect due to her "odd" behavior, she expressed no emotion. Lizzie was arrested and charged with murder.
The trial began on June 5 1893 in New Bedford Superior Court and lasted until June 20 1893. The jury heard lots of testimony and viewed evidence presented evidence during the trial, and then deliberated for barely one (1) hour before returning the verdict..."Not Guilty" at 3:42PM.
Lizzie A.Borden (1860-1927)
After the trial, Lizzie and Emma moved into a new house that Lizzie named "Maplecroft". The sisters settled all claims against them from Abby's side of the family, giving Abby Borden's family members everything, they wanted in order to avoid further lawsuits. It was determined that Abby died before Andrew, all of her estate legally went to Andrew, with Andrew's estate going to his daughters. The settlement reached between the Borden sisters and Abby's two sisters was substantial.
In June 1905, Lizzie and Emma Borden became estranged over differences in their lifestyles. Emma moved out of the house and moved in with her close friend Alice Lydia Buck. After the separation from her sister, Lizzie began using the name "Lizbeth A. Borden", rather than "Lizzie".
Following the surgical removal of her gallbladder, Lizzie was ill the last year of her life. Lizzie died of pneumonia on June 1, 1927. Lizzie's funeral details were not made public and few people attended her burial. She was buried in Oak Grove Cemetery under the name "Lizbeth Andrew Borden", her footstone was inscribed "Lizbeth". Lizzie never married, and her will, left $30,000 to the Fall River Animal Rescue League, $500 in perpetual trust for the care of her father's grave. Much of her wealth was transferred to her cousin Grace H. Howe, and her closest friend Helen Leighton. Nine days later, on June 10, 1927, her sister Emma died
Bridget Sullivan (1869-1948)
According to trial transcripts Bridget testified she prepared a meal for the Bordens and then was sent by Abby Borden to wash the windows. After finishing the windows in the heat, she retired to her room on the third-floor attic to rest, as she felt ill.
At 11:10AM Lizzie called to her "Maggie come quick! Father's dead, somebody came in and killed him." It was Bridget that discovered the body of Abby Borden dead in her bedroom. Bridget provided key testimony at the inquest, preliminary hearing and final trial of Lizzie Borden, who was later acquitted of all charges.
Bridget was born in Ireland and emigrated to the USA on May 24 1886 arriving in New York aboard the SS Republic. She began work as a maid in Newport, RI then moved to South Bethlehem Pennsylvania and lived with relatives. In 1888 Sullivan moved to Fall River Mass and worked as a cook for Lawyer Charles Reed, who resided in the Highland section of the city. In 1889 she then moved to the residence of Clinton Remington, also in the Highland section of the city. In November 1889 Bridget began her employment with the Borden Family.
After the trial in 1893, Bridget returned to Ireland with the help of Lizzie and Emma. Bridget later moved back to the USA and settled in Anaconda Montana, and in 1896 became the maid for Attorney George Winston (1861-1936). She remained employed by Winston until his death, never mentioning the murders in Massachusetts.
In 1905, Sullivan married John Sullivan (1868-1939) who was a copper smelting furnace man. In 1910 they resided at 412 Monroe St., then later moved to 701 Alder St where they lived for many years. After John Sullivan's death in 1939 she moved to Butte Montana and resided there until her death. Bridget and John are buried in Mount Olivet Cemetery in Anaconda Montana.
Sarah Marie Cornell Unsolved Murder 1832 Sarah was born in Rupert Vermont to James and Lucretia (Leffingwell) Cornell. Lucretia had become disowned by her father after she married James Cornell, who he did not approve of. James Cornell abandoned the family when Sarah was a baby, forcing Lucretia to give up her older daughter and son to relatives as she was financially unable to care for three children.
Sarah apprenticed as a tailor and finally worked at several mills throughout New England. Between 1823 and 1826 while working as a weaver in the mills, she had a transformation to Methodism, and sought to change her ways. In 1829 while working in Lowell MA she met a newly-arrived Methodist minister, Ephraim Kingsbury Avery. It was at a Methodist Camp Meeting in Thompson, Connecticut at the end of August 1832 that Sarah once again crossed paths with Reverend Avery. By this time, Avery had become the minster in Bristol, RI. It was alleged that during the Thompson Camp meeting that Avery seduced Sarah Cornell. In Oct 1832, Sarah moved to Fall River and was showing clear signs of pregnancy.
Sarah Cornell Found Dead
On December 21 1832, Sarah was found hanging in a barn on the farm of John Durfee in Tiverton, RI. Her body was identified by her minister, Reverend Ira Bidwell. Among her personal effects at her residence was a note written by Cornell and dated December 20 1832:
"If I should be missing, enquire of the Rev. Mr. Avery in Bristol. He will know where I am."
Other suspicious and incriminating letters were also discovered, as well as a conversation she had had with a doctor indicating the married Avery was the father of her unborn child. A coroner's jury was convened in Tiverton before any autopsy had been performed. This jury found that Cornell had "committed suicide by hanging herself upon a stake and was influenced to commit said crime by the wicked conduct of a married man." An autopsy was performed and it was confirmed Cornell was four months pregnant at the time of her death.
Sarah Cornell Buried
Sarah was buried on December 24, 1832 in an unmarked grave against a stone wall in the very field where she had been found. Her body was exhumed for a second autopsy. The Methodist Church rejected the responsibility of burying her the second time. The church claimed Cornell was a “probationary” member of the congregation and therefore the church wasn’t responsible for her burial. Responsibility for her burial was assumed by the Fall River Congregationalists, and Cornell was buried as an indigent, on December 24, 1832. In the 1868 the Durfee Farm was taken over by the City of Fall River and designated as “South Park” (today called “Kennedy Park”). Sarah was re interred in Oak Grove Cemetery Plot 2733 on Whitethorn Path.
Ephraim Kingsbury Formally Accused
A second coroner's jury was convened, this time in Bristol, RI. This jury overruled the earlier finding of suicide and accused Ephraim Kingsbury Avery as the "principal or accessory" in her death. Avery was quickly arrested on a charge of murder, but just as quickly set free on his own recognizance.
In Bristol RI, two Justices found there to be insufficient evidence to try Avery for the crime of murder. The people of Fall River were outraged so the deputy sheriff of Fall River, Harvey Hamden, obtained a warrant from a Rhode Island superior court judge for Avery's arrest. When a Rhode Island sheriff went to serve it, he discovered that Avery had already fled.
Ephraim Kingsbury Captured in New Hampshire
On January 20, 1833, Sheriff Hamden tracked Avery to Rindge, N.H. Avery later claimed he had fled because he feared for his life, particularly at the hands of the mob that had surrounded his house. Hamden extradited Avery to Newport, RI, where Avery was put in jail.
On March 8, 1833, Avery was indicted for murder by a Newport County grand jury. He plead "not guilty". The trial began in Newport, RI on May 6, 1833, and was heard by the Supreme Judicial Council. The trial lasted 27 days, and on June 2, 1833, after deliberating for 16 hours, the jury found Ephraim Kingsbury Avery "not guilty". The minister was set free and returned to his position in the Methodist Church, but the public opinion was that Avery had been wrongfully acquitted.
In 1836, Avery left the Methodist ministry, and took his family first to Connecticut, then upstate New York. He later resided in Ohio, became a farmer, and died on October 23, 1869
Sarah apprenticed as a tailor and finally worked at several mills throughout New England. Between 1823 and 1826 while working as a weaver in the mills, she had a transformation to Methodism, and sought to change her ways. In 1829 while working in Lowell MA she met a newly-arrived Methodist minister, Ephraim Kingsbury Avery. It was at a Methodist Camp Meeting in Thompson, Connecticut at the end of August 1832 that Sarah once again crossed paths with Reverend Avery. By this time, Avery had become the minster in Bristol, RI. It was alleged that during the Thompson Camp meeting that Avery seduced Sarah Cornell. In Oct 1832, Sarah moved to Fall River and was showing clear signs of pregnancy.
Sarah Cornell Found Dead
On December 21 1832, Sarah was found hanging in a barn on the farm of John Durfee in Tiverton, RI. Her body was identified by her minister, Reverend Ira Bidwell. Among her personal effects at her residence was a note written by Cornell and dated December 20 1832:
"If I should be missing, enquire of the Rev. Mr. Avery in Bristol. He will know where I am."
Other suspicious and incriminating letters were also discovered, as well as a conversation she had had with a doctor indicating the married Avery was the father of her unborn child. A coroner's jury was convened in Tiverton before any autopsy had been performed. This jury found that Cornell had "committed suicide by hanging herself upon a stake and was influenced to commit said crime by the wicked conduct of a married man." An autopsy was performed and it was confirmed Cornell was four months pregnant at the time of her death.
Sarah Cornell Buried
Sarah was buried on December 24, 1832 in an unmarked grave against a stone wall in the very field where she had been found. Her body was exhumed for a second autopsy. The Methodist Church rejected the responsibility of burying her the second time. The church claimed Cornell was a “probationary” member of the congregation and therefore the church wasn’t responsible for her burial. Responsibility for her burial was assumed by the Fall River Congregationalists, and Cornell was buried as an indigent, on December 24, 1832. In the 1868 the Durfee Farm was taken over by the City of Fall River and designated as “South Park” (today called “Kennedy Park”). Sarah was re interred in Oak Grove Cemetery Plot 2733 on Whitethorn Path.
Ephraim Kingsbury Formally Accused
A second coroner's jury was convened, this time in Bristol, RI. This jury overruled the earlier finding of suicide and accused Ephraim Kingsbury Avery as the "principal or accessory" in her death. Avery was quickly arrested on a charge of murder, but just as quickly set free on his own recognizance.
In Bristol RI, two Justices found there to be insufficient evidence to try Avery for the crime of murder. The people of Fall River were outraged so the deputy sheriff of Fall River, Harvey Hamden, obtained a warrant from a Rhode Island superior court judge for Avery's arrest. When a Rhode Island sheriff went to serve it, he discovered that Avery had already fled.
Ephraim Kingsbury Captured in New Hampshire
On January 20, 1833, Sheriff Hamden tracked Avery to Rindge, N.H. Avery later claimed he had fled because he feared for his life, particularly at the hands of the mob that had surrounded his house. Hamden extradited Avery to Newport, RI, where Avery was put in jail.
On March 8, 1833, Avery was indicted for murder by a Newport County grand jury. He plead "not guilty". The trial began in Newport, RI on May 6, 1833, and was heard by the Supreme Judicial Council. The trial lasted 27 days, and on June 2, 1833, after deliberating for 16 hours, the jury found Ephraim Kingsbury Avery "not guilty". The minister was set free and returned to his position in the Methodist Church, but the public opinion was that Avery had been wrongfully acquitted.
In 1836, Avery left the Methodist ministry, and took his family first to Connecticut, then upstate New York. He later resided in Ohio, became a farmer, and died on October 23, 1869